by buckmana » Wed Nov 06, 2013 5:13 pm
This was a tough one.
After reviewing the available data on their archery skills and agility, it seems they are equally matched in these fields, having no clear advantage.
However, when it comes to close quarters combat, Hawkeye has superior skills.
Green Arrow has only mastered one melee weapon, Hawkeye has mastered 4 (5 if we count Captain America's shield) and it is stated that should he choose to study other melee weapons, he would excel in using those as well.
I did an analysis of their unarmed martial arts abilities, Hawkeye is better at this then Green Arrow.
So, final result, all Hawkeye would have to do is get close to Green Arrow, fight him with a sword/melee weapon and/or martial arts and he wins.